This is very interesting. I did not know that, I thought Bujinkan members never sparred. I was reading a link in the wiki were it was stated that the nowadays way of training is a result of Soke’s illness. My objective is not to practice randori, but with this I see a mean to develop skills in the art. I have some friends who train other styles such as judo, BJJ or sambo. The way they train is very demanding and, even when I push myself to improve, they usually defeat me when we try some practice, then I reviewed what was wrong and what I found was that “dynamic” is the key word to this. The movement of a body is so complex that trying to perform a technique or a reaction under this is almost impossible with the fudoken based schema; the dynamic equilibrium for example, without moving how do I can avoid a takedown or a throw?
I respect my teacher who has also trained other arts and now is dedicated to Bujinkan, but I think the background he accumulated in his early practice makes him good, because he has a deeper knowledge of what you call “the foundation level” which -as you also note- does not exist in Bujinkan. The fundamentals of kicking, blocking, striking is the base of the pyramid, we practice Nage waza for example, but there is a lack of knowledge in how performing such techniques in movement. I like kata as the core practice in the dojo, but at least would be nice a free style where one can push oneself to adapt the “form” to an uncertain movement of the attacker.
Sheriff sensei, if you can, could you please send me those pictures you mentioned? I would like to develop a good argument to suggest increase our level in the dojo, as you said, not based in randori, but based in the physical preparation, kihon, kata, and maybe in a moment with sparring. But it seems good to show others the roots of the older shihan, feeling us as inheritor of such important and old tradition. I always have thought this is “the” martial art for me, because include the development of body and also due to its deeper philosophical roots.
Thanks again.